When doing research, you rely mainly on relevant and reliable sources. How do you get these? Two popular platforms you can use to access scholarly literature are Google Scholar and PubMed. But how do they compare? Which has more resources for clinical studies?

Key Takeaways

Google Scholar offers a broad, interdisciplinary range of literature, making it ideal for general and expansive searches.
PubMed focuses on peer-reviewed, high-quality, specialized biomedical and life sciences content.
Using Google Scholar and PubMed in tandem allows you to conduct more comprehensive literature reviews.

What Is Google Scholar?

Google Scholar is a free web search engine that indexes scholarly literature from various disciplines and sources, including journal articles, theses, books, abstracts, and court opinions.

One of Google Scholar's strengths is its broad coverage. It covers many disciplines, making it useful for interdisciplinary research. This search engine gives you relevant material from fields outside your primary study area.

Google Scholar's search algorithm also prioritizes highly cited articles, making it easier to identify influential papers. The search results display the citations each article has received to give you a quick indication of its impact and relevance.

Example of Google Scholar Search Results

When you search in Google Scholar, the results page displays a list of relevant articles, summaries, and citation information. Here's an example of what a typical search result might look like:

The search results also include links to access the full text directly from the publisher's website or your institution's library. Additionally, Google Scholar provides links to related articles, allowing you to explore similar research and expand your search.

What Is PubMed?

PubMed is a free search engine maintained by the National Library of Medicine. It primarily accesses the MEDLINE references database and abstracts on biomedical and life sciences topics. PubMed focuses on peer-reviewed literature from scientific journals.

PubMed's content is more specialized than Google Scholar's, making it a go-to resource for researchers in the biomedical and healthcare fields. The database contains over 30 million citations and abstracts from more than 7,000 journals, with coverage dating back to the 1950s.

PubMed's main selling point is its use of Medical Subject Headings (MeSH), a vocabulary thesaurus that indexes articles based on their content. This feature allows you to search for specific concepts and synonyms, even if the exact terms are not in the article's title or abstract.

PubMed also has advanced search features that enable you, for instance, to filter results by publication date, study type, and age group. These tools help you refine your search and find the most relevant articles for your research.

Example of PubMed Search Interface

When you visit the PubMed website, you'll see a simple search bar where you enter your query (as shown):

The search results page displays a list of citations matching your search terms, summaries, and links to the full text (if available). Here's an example of what a PubMed search result might look like:

pubmed search results for dementia in older adults

PubMed also provides tools to manage your search results, such as saving searches, creating email alerts, and exporting citations to reference management software (e.g., Zotero, Mendeley, Endnote).

Key Differences Between Google Scholar and PubMed

Although Google Scholar and PubMed are valuable for accessing scholarly literature, they differ in certain aspects.

Feature	Google Scholar	PubMed
Content Coverage	Covers a wide range of disciplines and sources, including non-peer-reviewed material	Focuses on biomedical and life sciences literature, primarily from peer-reviewed journals
Search Features	Uses a relevance algorithm that prioritizes highly cited articles	Uses MeSH terms to index articles based on content, enabling precise searches
Full-text Access	Provides links to full-text articles from various sources, including institutional repositories and preprint servers	Primarily links to publisher websites and PubMed Central, a free full-text archive of biomedical and life sciences journal literature
Citation Analysis	Displays the number of citations for each article and provides links to citing articles	Does not provide citation data but offers tools to find related articles and track article metrics through PubMed Central

Which Platform Should You Use for Clinical Research?

Choosing between Google Scholar and PubMed depends on your research project.

PubMed's specialized content and advanced search features may be more suitable if you're conducting a comprehensive literature review on a biomedical topic. The MeSH indexing system and filters help you find targeted, relevant results.

On the other hand, if your research involves interdisciplinary topics, Google Scholar's broad coverage and citation analysis features may be more helpful. The ability to find related articles and track citation patterns can help you identify key papers and trends in your study area.

In many cases, using both platforms ensures a thorough and well-rounded search. You can start with a broad search in Google Scholar to get an overview of the topic and identify the most cited articles, then use PubMed to drill down into the biomedical literature and find specific, peer-reviewed studies.

Ultimately, the key to an effective literature search is understanding each platform's strengths and limitations and using them strategically to support your research goals.

Benefits of Using Google Scholar for Clinical Research

Here are the major benefits of using Google Scholar for research:

Access to a Wide Range of Sources

Google Scholar's extensive coverage makes it valuable for clinical research, particularly when exploring a topic from multiple angles. The platform indexes scholarly literature from various disciplines, including the sciences, humanities, and social sciences.

This broad scope allows you to find relevant material from diverse sources such as academic publishers, professional societies, online repositories, and university websites.

For example, if you're researching the psychosocial aspects of a medical condition, Google Scholar can help you uncover valuable insights from psychology, sociology, and public health literature that may not be indexed in PubMed. This interdisciplinary approach provides a comprehensive understanding of the topic.

Highly Cited Articles

Google Scholar's search algorithm prioritizes articles based on relevance and citation count, making it easier to identify influential papers in a field. The search results display the number of times each article has been cited, underlining its impact and importance.

This feature is useful when searching for seminal works or landmark studies on a specific topic. By focusing on the most cited articles, you quickly identify the researchers and research groups in your area of interest and track the evolution of ideas and concepts over time.

Moreover, Google Scholar provides a "Cited by" link for each search result, showing the articles that have cited that particular paper. This helps you discover related research, identify emerging trends, and assess the influence of a study on subsequent work in the field.

Ease of Use and Familiarity

Google Scholar's interface is more intuitive and user-friendly than PubMed. The platform's simple search bar and familiar layout make it easy to start exploring a topic without having to learn complex query syntax or navigate multiple search fields.

Google Scholar's search engine also understands natural language queries, making it more forgiving of variations in terminology or phrasing. This feature is helpful when you're unfamiliar with the specific jargon or MeSH terms used in a particular field.

Additionally, Google Scholar's integration with other Google tools, like Google Docs and Google Drive, streamlines the process of saving and organizing relevant articles. You can easily save search results, create labels or folders, and access your library from any device with an internet connection.

While PubMed remains the go-to resource for many clinical researchers due to its focus on biomedical literature and advanced search features, Google Scholar's ease of use and broad coverage make it a valuable complementary tool.

Benefits of Using PubMed for Clinical Research

Here’s what PubMed offers:

High-Quality, Peer-Reviewed Literature

PubMed's primary focus on indexing peer-reviewed biomedical and life sciences journals ensures that the vast majority of literature on the platform has undergone rigorous evaluation by experts. This emphasis on high-quality, peer-reviewed content is important in clinical research, where the reliability and credibility of sources directly impact the validity of the findings and conclusions.

Moreover, PubMed's content is curated by the National Library of Medicine (NLM), which applies strict criteria for journal selection. The NLM evaluates journals based on scientific quality, editorial policies, and technical requirements before including them in the PubMed database to maintain the quality and trustworthiness of the literature.

Advanced Search Capabilities

PubMed offers advanced search features to refine queries and finds the most relevant articles for research. One of these is the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) thesaurus, a controlled vocabulary used to index articles based on their content.

MeSH terms are assigned to articles by trained indexers who review the full text and assign the most appropriate terms from the thesaurus. This ensures that articles are consistently and accurately indexed, even if the authors use different terminologies to describe similar concepts.

When you search using MeSH terms, you get articles that are conceptually related to your topic, even if they don't contain the exact keywords in your search. This feature is useful when dealing with complex or evolving medical terminologies, as it helps to find relevant articles that a simple keyword search might miss.

In addition to MeSH terms, PubMed provides search filters and tags to narrow down results based on specific criteria. For example, you can filter articles by publication date, study type (e.g., randomized controlled trial, meta-analysis), age group, sex, and language.

PubMed also supports advanced query syntax, such as Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT), proximity searching, and truncation to construct more precise and targeted searches.

Integration With Other NCBI Databases

PubMed is part of the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) suite of databases, which has a wealth of biomedical and genomic information resources. This integration enables seamless navigation between PubMed and other NCBI databases, enhancing the ability to find relevant information and explore connections between different data types.

For example, when you view an article in PubMed, you can easily access related information from other NCBI databases, such as:

GenBank: a database of genetic sequences
ClinicalTrials.gov: a registry and results database of publicly and privately supported clinical studies
PubChem: a database of chemical molecules and their activities against biological assays
MeSH: the controlled vocabulary thesaurus used for indexing articles in PubMed

Additionally, PubMed provides links to full-text articles in PubMed Central (PMC), a free digital repository of biomedical and life sciences literature. PMC contains over 7 million articles, including open-access journals and articles submitted by authors in compliance with public access policies from funding agencies like the National Institutes of Health (NIH).

Overall, PubMed's high-quality, peer-reviewed literature, advanced search capabilities, and integration with other NCBI databases make it an indispensable tool for clinical researchers.

How to Conduct Effective Searches in Google Scholar

Google Scholar's broad coverage and intuitive interface make it valuable for clinical research. But to get the most out of your searches, do the following:se:

Use Quotation Marks for Exact Phrases

When searching for a specific phrase, enclose it in quotation marks. This tells Google Scholar to search for the exact sequence of words rather than treating each word as a separate search term. For example, searching for "clinical trial protocol" will return results containing that exact phrase rather than articles mentioning clinical trials and protocols separately.

Utilize the Advanced Search Options

Google Scholar has an advanced search page for refining searches based on specific criteria. You can search for articles by author, publication, date range, and subject area. This feature is useful when you have a specific article in mind or want to narrow your results to a particular period or discipline.

Set Up Alerts for New Publications

You can stay up-to-date on the latest research by setting up alerts for new publications in your area of interest. To do this on Google Scholar, click the "Create alert" link at the bottom of the search results page. You'll receive email notifications whenever new articles matching your search criteria are added to the database.

When searching in Google Scholar, remember that the platform's relevance ranking algorithm may not always prioritize the most recent or clinically relevant articles. So, be prepared to sift through a larger volume of search results compared to PubMed. Also, the quality and applicability of the results should be evaluated.

How To Conduct Effective Searches in PubMed

Here are some strategies for conducting effective searches in PubMed:

Familiarize Yourself with Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)

MeSH terms are used to index articles in PubMed. Familiarizing yourself with relevant MeSH terms helps you find more precise and relevant search results. Start by searching for your topic in the MeSH database and exploring the related terms and subheadings.

Use Boolean Operators and Parentheses

PubMed supports the use of Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) to combine search terms. Use AND to narrow your search, OR to expand it, and NOT to exclude specific terms. Parentheses can be used to group terms and specify the order in which they're processed.

For example, searching for (hypertension OR "high blood pressure") AND (exercise OR "physical activity") will return articles that mention either hypertension or high blood pressure, along with either exercise or physical activity.

Take Advantage of Search Filters

PubMed has search filters on the left side of the search results page, allowing users to narrow down results based on specific criteria.

When searching in PubMed, it's essential to strike a balance between sensitivity and specificity. A sensitive search will retrieve many articles, some of which may not be directly relevant to your topic.

A specific search, on the other hand, may miss some relevant articles but will return a more focused set of results. Experiment with different combinations of MeSH terms, keywords, and filters to find an optimal balance for your research.

Combining Google Scholar and PubMed for Comprehensive Literature Searches

While Google Scholar and PubMed each have their strengths, using both platforms in tandem helps you conduct comprehensive and efficient literature searches. Here's a suggested workflow:

Start with a broad search in Google Scholar to get an overview of the topic and identify key terms, concepts, and authors. Use the "Cited by" and "Related articles" features to explore the citation network and discover additional relevant sources.

Next, use the insights gained from Google Scholar search to construct a more targeted search in PubMed. Incorporate relevant MeSH terms, keywords, and filters to refine your results and focus on high-quality, peer-reviewed studies.

Finally, review the most promising articles from both searches, critically appraise their methodological quality and relevance to your research question, and synthesize the evidence to inform your decision-making.

How to Optimize PubMed Searches for Clinical Research

To get the most relevant and reliable results, use these tips.

Utilize Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) Terms

Using the appropriate MeSH terms in your search helps you find articles most relevant to your research topic, even if the authors used different terminology.

To find the correct MeSH terms, search for your topic in the MeSH database and explore the related terms and subheadings. Once you've identified the most relevant MeSH terms, add them to your search query using the "MeSH Terms" field in the PubMed Advanced Search Builder.

Apply Filters to Narrow Results

PubMed has filters for narrowing search results based on specific criteria. For example, if you're interested in randomized controlled trials, select the "Randomized Controlled Trial" filter under the "Article Type" category. Similarly, if you want to focus on studies published within the last five years, you can use the "Publication Date" filter to specify your desired date range.

Save and Manage Search Queries

As you conduct searches in PubMed, saving and managing your search queries can save you time and effort. PubMed allows you to save search queries and create email alerts for new articles matching your search criteria.

To save a search query, click the "Create alert" button on the search results page. You will receive email alerts whenever new articles matching your search are added to PubMed, or you can manually check your saved searches anytime.

Saving search queries also makes it easier to refine and update subsequent searches as your research progresses. You can combine saved searches using Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT) to create more complex and targeted queries.

When conducting research, evaluating the quality of the studies is just as crucial as finding relevant articles. PubMed's peer-reviewed biomedical literature ensures that the studies are of high quality. However, it's still important to appraise each article before incorporating it into your research.

Tips for Integrating Google Scholar and PubMed in Clinical Research

Here is how to use both Google Scholar and PubMmed in research:

Start With PubMed for Core Biomedical Literature

When conducting clinical research, begin your search on PubMed. Its MeSH indexing system allows you to search for specific concepts and synonyms, even if the exact terms are not in the article's title or abstract.

Expand Search With Google Scholar for Additional Perspectives

After searching PubMed, use Google Scholar to broaden your literature search and gain additional perspectives on your research topic. Google Scholar covers many disciplines and sources, including non-peer-reviewed material such as preprints, conference proceedings, and gray literature.

This expanded coverage can help you identify emerging trends, interdisciplinary connections, and novel approaches that may not be captured in PubMed's more focused database.

When using Google Scholar, remember that the quality and reliability of sources may vary. Exercise caution when evaluating non-peer-reviewed material, and always assess the credibility and relevance of the information before incorporating it into your research.

Evaluate the Quality and Relevance of Results from Both Platforms

As you search using PubMed and Google Scholar, evaluate the quality and relevance of the results. Assess each article's methodological rigor, sample size, and statistical analyses to determine its strength of evidence and applicability to your research question.

Consider the journal's reputation, the authors' expertise, and the study's funding sources when weighing the credibility of the findings. Additionally, examine how well the article aligns with your research objectives and target population.

Appraising the results is an ongoing process that requires practice and expertise. Consult experts to hone your judgment skills on the quality and relevance of the studies.

Which Platform Is Best for Clinical Research?

The best platform depends on your research question. PubMed and Google Scholar each have unique strengths that can benefit your literature search in different ways.

PubMed is the go-to choice for comprehensive searches of biomedical literature. Its high-quality, peer-reviewed journals are reliable and relevant to most research questions. Its advanced search features allow you to quickly refine your search and find the most pertinent studies.

On the other hand, Google Scholar is a valuable complementary tool to expand a search beyond PubMed's scope. It is broad and includes non-peer-reviewed material that may not be in PubMed. So, when deciding which platform to use, consider:

The specificity of your research question
The importance of peer-reviewed sources for your study
The need for interdisciplinary perspectives or gray literature
Your familiarity with each platform's search features and interfaces

For brands seeking to validate their wellness products with clinical trials, book a call today with Reputable Health.

Google Scholar vs Pubmed: Which Is Best for Clinical Research?